Stagnation in Large-Scale Solar Thermal Systems? Experiences From Recent Installations as Motivation for Heat Pipe Collectors in a Novel System Design

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.52825/st-symposium.v2i.2747

Keywords:

Large-Scale Solar Thermal Systems, Stagnation Load, Heat Pipe, Overheating Prevention, Cost Efficiency

Abstract

Large-scale solar thermal systems supplying heating networks can make a significant contribution to the decarbonization of the heating sector and are becoming increasingly relevant in practice. The first part of the paper analyses 30 realized systems in Germany focusing on collector area, heat storage capacity and stagnation events. More than 60 % of these systems have heat storage capacities smaller than 100 l/m² collector area. Nevertheless, a third of the systems reaches an annual solar fraction of over 20 %. Our investigations for such dimensioned systems report a number of 20 to 43 stagnation days per year, depending on the storage capacity. The relevance of stagnation load motivates our research activities to avoid its negative consequences in large-scale systems. The second part of the paper describes the development of evacuated tube collectors with inherent overheating prevention as well as the outdoor tests we carried out with various prototypes at our sun tracker. The collector concepts are based on heat pipes with temperature limitation to 125-135 °C in the solar circuit and are therefore able to avoid evaporation of the heat transfer medium. Due to lower stagnation loads, we investigate the possibility of using polymeric pipes instead of steel pipes for the solar circuit and discuss an integrated system concept. The innovative collector and system design are implemented in a demonstration plant that we will monitor during the construction phase and in operation.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

[1] R. Ehrig et al: „Wie gelingt die Dekarbonisierung der Fernwärme: Vier zentrale Herausforderungen auf dem Weg zur Klimaneutralität bis 2045.“ Hrsg.: Deutsche Energie-Agentur GmbH (dena).

https://www.dena.de/fileadmin/dena/Publikationen/PDFs/2023/IMPULSPAPIER_Wie_gelingt_die_Dekarbonisierung_der_Fernwaerme.pdf (accessed at Mai 05, 2025)

[2] S. Hay: “Existing District Heating Networks in Context of German Climate Goals: Potentials for UrbanTurn.” ISEC Conference Graz, 07th April 2022. https://www.aee-intec.at/0uploads/dateien1661.pdf (accessed at Mai 05, 2025)

[3] G. Bröer: „Größte Solarthermieanlage Deutschlands in Greifswald eingeweiht.“ Solarthemen Media GmbH, https://www.solarserver.de/2023/03/22/solare-waermenetze-in-deutschland-starker-zuwachs-in-2022/?utm_source=newsletter&utm_campaign=newsletter. (accessed at Mai 05, 2025)

[4] Solites: „Solarthermie in der Fernwärme: 2024 kaum Zuwachs.“ Solarthemen Media GmbH, https://www.solarserver.de/2025/04/03/solarthermie-in-der-fernwaerme-2024-kaum-zuwachs/?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=linkedin (accessed at Mai 05, 2025)

[5] Rehau: „Effizienz-Technologie Nahwärme.“ Die Zukunft von Raumheizung und Warmwasser, https://www.rehau.com/downloads/404296/kommunale-waermeinfrastruktur-referenzen.pdf. (accessed at Mai 09, 2025)

[6] B. Schiebler et al: „Solarthermische Großanlagen in Wärmenetzen: Eine Analyse von Machbarkeitsstudien und Messdaten aus realisierten Projekten.“ 33. Symposium Solarthermie und innovative Wärmesysteme, Bad Staffelstein, Mai 2023.

[7] Ritter-XL: „Offizielle Inbetriebnahme Solarpark Mühlhausen“, https://www.ritter-xl-solar.de/offizielle-inbetriebnahme-solarpark-muehlhausen. (accessed at Mai 05, 2025)

[8] Bröer, G: „Größte Solarthermieanlage Deutschlands in Greifswald eingeweiht“, Solarthemen Media GmbH, https://www.solarserver.de/2022/09/17/groesste-solarthermieanlage-deutschlands-in-greifswald-eingeweiht. (accessed at Mai 05, 2025)

[9] Solites: Bildnachweis zur Solarhermieanlage und Heizzentrale in Ellern, https://www.solare-waermenetze.de/mediathek/fotos-und-videos/?mgi_100=1529/solarthermieanlage-und-heizzentrale-in-ellern. (accessed at Mai 05, 2025)

[10] Ritter-XL: „Solarunterstützte Wärmenetze für Dörfer Hallerndorf in Oberfranken.“, https://www.ritter-xl-solar.de/anwendungen/waermenetze/hallerndorf/?nowprocket=1. (accessed at Mai 05, 2025)

[11] Ch. Fink et al: Wissenschaftliche Begleitforschung zum Förderprogramm „Solarthermie – Solare Großanlagen“ 2010-2015, https://solarthermalworld.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/solare_grossanlagen_2010-2015_aggregierter_bericht.pdf. (accessed at Mai 20, 2025)

[12] Viessmann: „Planungshandbuch Solarthermie“, Allendorf 2008.

[13] R. Meißner: „Technische Herausforderungen mit Großflächen-Solarthermie für die Fernwärme.“ 32. Symposium Solarthermie und innovative Wärmesysteme, Bad Staffelstein, Mai 2022.

[14] E. Frank et al: “Overheating prevention and stagnation handling in solar process heat applications”, IEA SHC Task 49, Technical Report A.1.2, https://task49.iea-shc.org/Data/Sites/7/frank_iea_shc_task49_overheatingstagnationreport_approved_v-2-3.pdf. (accessed at Mai 30, 2025)

[15] B. Schiebler et al: “Heat pipe collectors with overheating prevention in a cost-optimized system concept: Monitoring of system performance and stagnation loads under real conditions.” Solar Energy Advances, vol. 3, 100040, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.seja.2023.100040, 2023.

[16] ISO 9806: “Solar energy – Solar thermal collectors – Test methods.” Beuth Verlag, Berlin, 2018.

[17] ENEPIPE: “Rohrsysteme – Technische Information“,

https://www.enerpipe.de/fileadmin/daten/02_produkte/06_Rohre-und-Verbindungstechnik/Rohrsysteme_TI_821000100_04-2021_web.pdf. (accessed at Mai 08, 2025)

[18] Brugg: „CALPEX-Fernwärmeleitung – Technisches Datenblatt“,

https://www.bruggpipes.com/fileadmin/user_upload/downloads/produkte/01-nah-und-fernwaerme/calpex/calpex-anschlussverbindungen/brugg-rohrsysteme-calpex-katalog_de.pdf. (accessed at Mai 08, 2025)

[19] ISO 19893: “Plastics piping systems – Thermoplastics pipes and fittings for hot and cold water – Test method for the resistance of mounted assemblies to temperature cycling.” Beuth Verlag, Berlin, 2018.

[20] Viega: „Innovative Rohrverbindungstechnik von Viega“, https://www.produktion.de/innovative_rohrverbindungstechnik_von_viega/pressen-statt-schweissen-bei-extremen-industrieanwendungen-122.html. (accessed at Mai 09, 2025)

Downloads

Published

2026-02-26

How to Cite

Schiebler, B., Kirchner, M., Jensen, J., & Giovannetti, F. (2026). Stagnation in Large-Scale Solar Thermal Systems? Experiences From Recent Installations as Motivation for Heat Pipe Collectors in a Novel System Design. Solarthermie-Symposium Proceedings, 2. https://doi.org/10.52825/st-symposium.v2i.2747

Conference Proceedings Volume

Section

Conference Papers
Received 2025-06-07
Accepted 2025-09-20
Published 2026-02-26

Funding data