Farm Investment and Adoption of Fixed Milk Price Contracts on Irish Dairy Farms




Dairy Farm Investment, Contract Farming, Fixed Milk Price Contracts, Risk Management, 2SRI Approach


After the milk quota removal in 2015, the Irish dairy industry has expanded dramatically. Various economic, social and environmental considerations are part of farmer’s choice to invest and to expand. This study evaluates selected factors contributing to recent dairy farmer’s investment decisions and examines the relationship between the adoption of Fixed Milk Price Contracts as a risk management tool and farm investments. This research applies the two-stage residual inclusion approach to address this research question using Teagasc NFS data from 2016 to 2021. This approach is applied to control for potential endogeneity including risk aversion. The results point to the economic relevance of the FMC adoption towards farm investment decisions although the magnitude of the association is limited. Subsidies play an important role in the investment decision although they are a small proportion in the overall specialised dairy farm income and provide a relatively stable source of income in Ireland. We finally conclude that, there is scope to improve the design of these FMCs in terms of protecting farmers from drastic margin volatility and to increase the adoption rate


Download data is not yet available.


Amrhein, V., Greenland, S., Mcshane, B. (2019): Scientists rise up against statistical signifi-cance. Nature 567 (7748): 305-307. DOI:

Aramyan, L.H., Lansink, A.G.O., Verstegen, J.A. (2007). Factors underlying the investment decision in energy-saving systems in Dutch horticulture. Agricultural systems 94 (2): 520-527. DOI:

Arata, L., Cerroni, S., Santeramo, F.G., Trestini, S., Severini, S. (2023): Towards a holistic approach to sustainable risk management in agriculture in the EU: a literature review. Bio-based and Applied Economics 12 (3). DOI:

Beal, D.J. (1996): Emerging issues in risk management in farm firms. Review of Marketing and Agricultural Economics 64 (430-2016-31462): 336-347.

Bellemare, M.F., Wichman, C.J. (2020): Elasticities and the inverse hyperbolic sine transfor-mation. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics 82 (1): 50-61. DOI:

Bellemare, M.F., Lee, Y.N., Novak, L. (2021): Contract farming as partial insurance. World Development 140: 105274. DOI:

Bertoni, D., Cavicchioli, D., Latruffe, L. (2023): Impact of business transfer on economic per-formance: the case of Italian family farms. International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Small Business 48 (2): 186-213. DOI:

Borchers, M.R., Bewley, J.M. (2015): An assessment of producer precision dairy farming technology use, pre-purchase considerations, and usefulness. Journal of Dairy Science 98 (6): 4198-4205. DOI:

Bradfield, T., Butler, R., Dillon, E. J., Hennessy, T., Loughrey, J. (2023): The impact of long-term land leases on farm investment: Evidence from the Irish dairy sector. Land Use Poli-cy 126: 106553. DOI:

Calus, M., Van Huylenbroeck, G., Van Lierde, D. (2008): The relationship between farm suc-cession and farm assets on Belgian farms. Sociologia Ruralis 48 (1): 38-56. DOI:

Cameron, A.C., Trivedi, P.K. (2005): Microeconometrics: methods and applications. Cam-bridge University Press, Cambridge. DOI:

Central Statistic Office (CSO) (2021):

Chavas, J.P., Klemme, R.M. (1986): Aggregate milk supply response and investment behav-ior on U.S. dairy farms. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 68 (1): 55-66. DOI:

Coffey, B.K., Schroeder, T.C. (2019): Factors influencing Midwestern grain farmers’ use of risk management tools. Agricultural Finance Review 79 (2): 192-203. DOI:

Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (2023):

Dillon, P., Shalloo, L., …, Hennessy, D. (2020): Review of the influence of chemical nitrogen application rate, soil type and agro-climate location on grass production, feed budgets, ni-trogen use efficiency, environmental impact and farm profitability (No. hal-03034194).

Du, X., Feng, H., Hennessy, D.A. (2017): Rationality of choices in subsidized crop insurance markets. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 99 (3): 732-756. DOI:

Duden, C., Offermann, F. (2020): Income risk of German farms and its drivers. German Journal of Agricultural Economics 69 (2): 85-107. DOI:

European Commission, Directorate-General for Agriculture and Rural Development (2017): Study on risk management in EU agriculture – Final report. Publications Office.

Eurostat (2022):

Feinerman, E., Peerlings, J. (2005): Uncertain land availability and investment decisions: The case of Dutch dairy farms. Journal of Agricultural Economics 56 (1): 59-80. DOI:

Fertő, I., Bojnec, Š., Fogarasi, J., Viira, A.H. (2021): The investment behaviour of dairy farms in transition economies. Baltic Journal of Economics 21 (1): 60-84. DOI:

Finance Ireland (2018): Milk Flex Booklet.

Finneran, E., Crosson, P., O’Kiely, P., Shalloo, L., Forristal, P.D., Wallace, M. (2012): Eco-nomic modelling of an integrated grazed and conserved perennial ryegrass forage produc-tion system. Grass and Forage Science 67 (2): 162-176. DOI:

Frick, F., Sauer, J. (2021): Technological change in dairy farming with increased price volatili-ty. Journal of Agricultural Economics 72 (2): 564-588. DOI:

Garcia-Covarrubias, L., Läpple, D., Dillon, E., Thorne, F. (2023): Automation and efficiency: a latent class analysis of Irish dairy farms. Q Open, qoad015. DOI:

Garvey, J., Sirr, G., O'Shea, D., O'Brien, F. (2019): Risk and planning in agriculture: how planning on dairy farms in Ireland is affected by farmers’ regulatory focus. Risk Analy-sis 39 (7): 1491-1502. DOI:

Giles, D.E. (2011): Interpreting dummy variables in semi-logarithmic regression models: Ex-act distributional results. University of Victoria, Department of Economics Working Paper EWP 1101: 1-24.

Gogtay, N.J., Thatte, U.M. (2017): Principles of correlation analysis. Journal of the Associa-tion of Physicians of India 65 (3): 78-81.

Goodwin, B.K., Schroeder, T.C. (1994): Human capital, producer education programs, and the adoption of forward‐pricing methods. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 76 (4): 936-947. DOI:

Goodwin, B.K. (1993): An empirical analysis of the demand for multiple peril crop insurance. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 75 (2): 425-434. DOI:

Hadrich, J.C., Johnson, K.K. (2015): Estimation of risk management effects on revenue and purchased feed costs on US dairy farms. Journal of Dairy Science 98 (9): 6588-6596. DOI:

Halvorsen, R., Palmquist, R. (1980): The interpretation of dummy variables in semilogarithmic equations. American Economic Review 70 (3): 474-475. DOI:

Hardaker, J. B., Lien, G. (2010): Probabilities for decision analysis in agriculture and rural re-source economics: The need for a paradigm change. Agricultural Systems 103 (6): 345-350. . DOI:

Hardaker, J.B., Huirne, R.B.M., Anderson, J.R., Lien, G. (2004): Introduction to risk in agricul-ture. In: Coping with risk in agriculture: 1-22. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, UK. DOI:

Heckelei, T., Hüttel, S., Odening, M., Rommel, J. (2023): The p-Value Debate and Statistical (Mal) practice–Implications for the Agricultural and Food Economics Community. German Journal of Agricultural Economics 72 (1): 47-67. DOI:

Hoehl, S., Hess, S. (2022): Liquidity, hedging and the survival of North German dairy farms. European Review of Agricultural Economics 49 (1): 208-236. DOI:

Irish Farmer’s Association (IFA) (2021): The Irish Dairy sector - a good news story. Sto-ry.pdf.

Ifft, J.E., Kuethe, T., Morehart, M. (2015): Does federal crop insurance lead to higher farm debt use? Evidence from the Agricultural Resource Management Survey (ARMS). Agri-cultural Finance Review 75 (3): 349-367. DOI:

Kelly, P., Shalloo, L., Wallace, M., Dillon, P. (2020): The Irish dairy industry–Recent history and strategy, current state and future challenges. International Journal of Dairy Technolo-gy 73 (2): 309-323. DOI:

Key, N., Mcbride, W.D. (2008): Do production contracts raise farm productivity? An instru-mental variables approach. Agricultural and Resource Economics Review 37 (2): 176-187. DOI:

Komarek, A.M., De Pinto, A., Smith, V.H. (2020): A review of types of risks in agriculture: What we know and what we need to know. Agricultural Systems 178. 102738. DOI:

Kuethe, T.H., Morehart, M. (2012): The profit impacts of risk management tool adoption. Ag-ricultural Finance Review, Emerald Group Publishing 72 (1): 104-116, May. DOI:

Ladue, E., Miller, L., Kwiatkowski, J. (1989): Factors Influencing Farm Investment Behavior. Department of Agricultural Economics-North Dakota State University, Fargo, Agricultural Economics Report No 243: 37-49.

Läpple, D., Sirr, G. (2019): Dairy intensification and quota abolition: a comparative study of production in Ireland and the Netherlands. EuroChoices 18 (3): 26-32. DOI:

Läpple, D., Hennessy, T., O’Donovan, M. (2012): Extended grazing: a detailed analysis of Irish dairy farms. Journal of Dairy Science 95 (1): 188-195. DOI:

Leppälä, J., Rautiainen, R., Kauranen, I. (2015): Analysis of risk management tools applicable in managing farm risks: A literature review. International Journal of Agricultural Manage-ment 4 (3): 110-122.

Levi, L., Latruffe, L., Ridier, A. (2017): The role of farm performance on investment decisions: evidence from the French (Brittany) dairy sector. 34. Journées de Microéconomie Appli-quées (JMA): 20-p.

Lindena, T., Hess, S. (2022): Is animal welfare better on smaller dairy farms? Evidence from 3,085 dairy farms in Germany. Journal of Dairy Science 105 (11): 8924-8945. DOI:

Loughrey, J., O’Connor, D., Donnellan, T., Hennessy, T., Thorne, F. (2021): Income Volatility on Dairy Farms in Ireland. Journal of the Statistical and Social Inquiry Society of Ireland 50 (4).

Loughrey, J., Thorne, F., Donnellan, T., Hennessy, T., O’Connor, D. (2018): An evaluation of suitable tools to manage price/income volatility at dairy farm level in Ireland. Technical re-port, Dairy Research Ireland.

Loughrey, J., Thorne, F., Kinsella, A., Hennessy, T., O'Donoghue, C., Vollenweider, X. (2015): Market risk management and the demand for forward contracts among Irish dairy farmers. International Journal of Agricultural Management 4 (4): 173-180.

Ma, W., Zhu, Z. (2020): A note: reducing cropland abandonment in China–do agricultural co-operatives play a role? Journal of Agricultural Economics 71 (3): 929-935. . DOI:

Ma, W., Renwick, A., Bicknell, K. (2018): Higher intensity, higher profit? Empirical evidence from dairy farming in New Zealand. Journal of Agricultural Economics 69 (3): 739-755. DOI:

Mahul, O., Stutley, C.J. (2008): Government support to agricultural insurance. Challenges and options for developing countries. The World Bank, Washington, DC: 12. DOI:

Margarian, A. (2022): Beyond p-value-obsession: when are statistical hypothesis tests re-quired and appropriate? German Journal of Agricultural Economics 71 (4): 213-226. DOI:

Mayen, C.D., Balagtas, J.V., Alexander, C.E. (2010): Technology adoption and technical effi-ciency: organic and conventional dairy farms in the United States. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 92 (1): 181-195. DOI:

Meraner, M., Finger, R. (2019): Risk perceptions, preferences and management strategies: evidence from a case study using German livestock farmers. Journal of Risk Research 22 (1): 110-135. DOI:

Michels, M., Möllmann, J., Musshoff, O. (2019): Understanding the intention to use commodi-ty futures contracts. Agricultural Finance Review 79 (5): 582-597. DOI:

Müller, M., Hanisch, M., Malvido, A., Rommel, J., Sagebiel, J. (2018): The structural effect of cooperatives on price volatility in the European dairy sector. Applied Economics Letters 25 (8): 576-579. DOI:

Murphy, D.J., Murphy, M.D., O’Brien, B., O’Donovan, M. (2021): A review of precision tech-nologies for optimising pasture measurement on Irish grassland. Agriculture 11 (7): 600. DOI:

O’Toole, C., Hennessy, T. (2015): Do decoupled payments affect investment financing con-straints? Evidence from Irish agriculture. Food Policy 56: 67-75. DOI:

Petersen, J., Hess, S. (2018): The future of milk delivery relations from the perspective of German farmers. German Journal of Agricultural Economics 67 (2): 80-94.

Prager, D., Burns, C., Tulman, S., Macdonald, J. (2020): Farm use of futures, options, and marketing contracts. USDA-ERS Economic Information Bulletin 219: 1-39.

Revenue (2021): Income Averaging. employment/farm/farming/income-averaging.aspx

Samson, G.S., Gardebroek, C., Jongeneel, R.A. (2016): Explaining production expansion decisions of Dutch dairy farmers. NJAS-Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences 76: 87-98. DOI:

Schulte, H., Musshoff, O. (2018a): Insurance prospects after the European dairy quota aboli-tion. Agricultural Finance Review 78 (2): 223-232. DOI:

Schulte, H.D., Musshoff, O., Meuwissen, M.P.M. (2018b): Considering milk price volatility for investment decisions on the farm level after European milk quota abolition. Journal of dairy science 101 (8): 7531-7539. DOI:

Severini, S., Zinnanti, C., Borsellino, V., Schimmenti, E. (2021): EU income stabilization tool: potential impacts, financial sustainability and farmer’s risk aversion. Agricultural and Food Economics 9 (1): 1-21. DOI:

Shalloo, L., Connor, D.O., Cele, L., Thorne, F., Egan, M. (2020): An analysis of the Irish dairy sector post quota. Teagasc, Cork, Ireland.

Skevas, I., Emvalomatis, G., Brümmer, B. (2018b): Productivity growth measurement and decomposition under a dynamic inefficiency specification: The case of German dairy farms. European Journal of Operational Research 271 (1): 250-261. DOI:

Špička, J., Boudný, J., Janotová, B. (2009): The role of subsidies in managing the operating risk of agricultural enterprises. Agricultural Economics 55 (4): 169-180. DOI:

Terza, J.V. (2018): Two‐stage residual inclusion estimation in health services research and health economics. Health services research 53(3): 1890-1899. DOI:

Thorsøe, M., Noe, E., Maye, D., Vigani, M., Kirwan, J., Chiswell, H., Grivins, M., Adamsone- Fiskovica, A., Tisenkopfs, T., Tsakalou, E., Aubert, P.M., Loveluck, W. (2020): Respond-ing to change: Farming system resilience in a liberalized and volatile European dairy mar-ket. Land Use Policy 99: 105029. DOI:

Tirlan Farm Life (2022): Glanbia Ireland Fixed Milk Price Scheme – Phase 18.|

Ton, G., Vellema, W., Desiere, S., Weituschat, S., D'Haese, M. (2018): Contract farming for improving smallholder incomes: What can we learn from effectiveness studies? World De-velopment 104: 46-64. DOI:

Trestini, S., Chinchio, E. (2018): Simulation of a mutual fund to stabilise the income of farms belonging to a dairy cooperative.Italian Review of Agricultural Economics 73(3): 37-52.

U.S Department Of Agriculture (2019): Dairy Forward Pricing Program.

Van Asseldonk, M., Tzouramani, I., Ge, L., Vrolijk, H. (2016): Adoption of risk management strategies in European agriculture. Studies in Agricultural Economics 118 (3): 154-162. DOI:

Van Winsen, F., De Mey, Y., Lauwers, L., Van Passel, S., Vancauteren, M., Wauters, E. (2016): Determinants of risk behaviour: effects of perceived risks and risk attitude on farmer’s adoption of risk management strategies. Journal of Risk Research 19 (1): 56-78. DOI:

Vigani, M. and Kathage, J. (2019): To risk or not to risk? Risk management and farm produc-tivity. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 101 (5): 1432-1454. DOI:

Vrolijk, H., Poppe, K. (2020): Impact of off-farm income and paid taxes on the composition and volatility of incomes and wealth of dairy farmers in the Netherlands. Studies in Agricul-tural Economics 122 (2): 57-65. DOI:

Wolf, C.A., Karszes, J. (2023): Financial risk and resiliency on US dairy farms: Measures, thresholds, and management implications. Journal of Dairy Science 106 (5): 3301-3311. DOI:

Wolf, C.A., Widmar, N.J.O. (2014): Adoption of milk and feed forward pricing methods by dairy farmers. Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 46 (4): 527-541. DOI:

Wolf, C.A. (2012): Dairy farmer use of price risk management tools. Journal of dairy science 95 (7): 4176-4183. DOI:

Wright, W., Brown, P.J.N.Z.E.P. (2019): Succession and investment in New Zealand farming. New Zealand Economic Papers 53(2): 203-214. DOI:




How to Cite

Pardeshi, S., Loughrey, J., & O'Connor, D. (2024). Farm Investment and Adoption of Fixed Milk Price Contracts on Irish Dairy Farms. German Journal of Agricultural Economics, 73(1).